The recent debut of Ellie Taylor as the new host for 'Strictly Come Dancing: It Takes Two' has ignited a wave of criticism from viewers, who are voicing their displeasure over the show's refreshed format. Many perceive Taylor's comedic delivery as unnatural and forced, while the decision to feature celebrity contestants without their professional dance partners has been widely condemned. These changes coincide with a notable decline in viewership for the main 'Strictly Come Dancing' live show, signaling a challenging period for the popular BBC franchise.
Ellie Taylor, a former contestant on 'Strictly' in 2022, took the reins of 'It Takes Two' following the departure of Fleur East and Janette Manrara. Her inaugural episode, which aired after the initial live show of the season, was met with a barrage of negative feedback. Viewers utilized social media platforms to label the format overhaul as a 'total downgrade,' lamenting the absence of the familiar dynamic between couples. The new structure, which sees celebrities interviewed individually rather than as pairs, has been a significant point of contention, with many feeling it detracts from the show's original appeal.
The main 'Strictly Come Dancing' live show also experienced a considerable drop in ratings, marking the first time in seven years that it attracted fewer viewers than its pre-recorded launch episode. This decline has been attributed by some to the introduction of a new presenting trio—Josh Widdicombe, Emma Willis, and Johannes Radebe—who replaced long-standing hosts Tess Daly and Claudia Winkleman. Critics have pointed out awkward moments and missed cues from the new hosts, particularly Josh Widdicombe, who some viewers felt was a 'spare part' in the revamped lineup. His placement alongside the more experienced Emma Willis, often delivering punchlines to her commentary, drew particular scrutiny.
During one live broadcast, Widdicombe notably missed his cue, causing an awkward silence before introducing the next dance pair. This incident, which recurred later in the show, highlighted perceived inexperience among the new hosts. Even judge Motsi Mabuse playfully chided Widdicombe during her feedback to Paralympian Dame Sarah Storey, adding to the sense of a disjointed presentation. While some fans praised Ellie Taylor's presenting skills on 'It Takes Two,' the overwhelming sentiment points to a general dissatisfaction with the changes across both 'Strictly' programs. Many believe the BBC's modifications to what was once a winning formula have resulted in a less engaging and cohesive viewing experience, with calls for a return to previous structures and hosting arrangements.
The recent format adjustments and hosting changes for 'Strictly Come Dancing' and its companion show, 'It Takes Two,' have faced substantial criticism from the audience. Viewers have expressed dissatisfaction with new host Ellie Taylor's performance and the revised interview style on 'It Takes Two,' which now separates celebrity contestants from their professional partners. This backlash comes amidst a downturn in ratings for the main live show, leading to a debate about whether the BBC's alterations to a beloved entertainment staple have alienated its loyal fanbase.